Yard Sale Pizza Reviews

The slices were seriously big, and I could tell as soon as they came out that I wasn’t going to need much. I got full fast, so it felt like a good deal to me

It took longer than I expected, so that was a little frustrating. It wasn’t a huge deal, but I’d hoped it’d be quicker

The place was fine overall, but the tables just felt a little dirty, if that makes sense. Like they’d been wiped down quickly but not really cleaned properly.

I grabbed one of their special offers and it made dinner a lot more affordable. The pizza showed up hot, the crust still had a nice crisp to it, and the cheese and toppings tasted fresh instead of rushed. No hassle with the order either, which I always appreciate. I’d definitely order again, especially when they’ve got those deals running...

My order came exactly how I wanted it, so I’m happy. No issues on my end, and it was nice not having to deal with anything extra

Had pizza here and the drink choices were good, good. Nice to have a few options to go with the food.

To be fair, the desserts tasted fine and weren’t bad at all. I just didn’t feel like they were as fresh as I was hoping for, so they didn’t really stand out to me...

The pizza showed up actually hot, not just kind of warm, and that made a huge difference. The cheese was still melty and the crust tasted like it had just come out of the oven. I’ve definitely had delivery pizza arrive looking sad before, but this one was the perfect temperature and I ate it right away with no microwave needed. My only small note is I would’ve liked a little clearer instructions or updates on the delivery timing, but the pizza itself was great. 5 stars from me.

I tried the gluten-free crust it was good. It’s not perfect, but it was tasty and actually held up well, which isn’t always the case with gluten-free pizza. Compared to a few other places I’ve tried, this one had better texture and didn’t fall apart halfway through. I just wish they had a few more gluten-free options to choose from

I picked up my pizza with no hassle at all. It was ready when I got there, the staff were friendly, and everything felt straightforward. Fair to say it was an easy, positive experience.

I've ordered from yardsalepizza a few times now, and the delivery has been really dependable. The food shows up when they say it will, even on a busy Friday night (which impressed me). The driver was friendly too. No random delays or missing items so far, and at this point, that’s pretty much all I’m asking for.

I reached out to support and waited way longer than I expected for a reply. Not the worst experience ever, but it just felt...

I had an issue with my order i was annoyed at first. I reached out to yardsalepizza not expecting much, but they replied faster than I thought they would. They actually listened, kept it straightforward, and helped get things sorted out without making it awkward. I’m still a little unsure about the overall quality after the mix-up, but I will say their customer support was really solid. Mistakes happen, and the way they handled it definitely made me more open to ordering from them again.

I tried yardsalepizza.com hoping they’d have a few more vegan choices, it was just okay. The delivery was totally fine, no issues there, and the pizza itself wasn’t bad. But if you don’t eat dairy, there really isn’t a ton to choose from. The vegan cheese was alright, like, it did the job, but it wasn’t anything amazing. I’d maybe order again, but probably only if they added more toppings or put together a proper vegan menu.

I tried yardsalepizza mostly because I was looking for vegetarian options, so I feel like I gave it a fair shot. It was fine overall, not bad at all, just not something I’d go out of my way to order again. The veggie pizza actually had good flavor, but I kept wishing there were more choices or some more interesting topping combos. Ordering was easy, so no complaints there. If my friends wanted to get it, I’d eat it again, but if I’m choosing, it probably wouldn’t be my first pick

The crust came out just right, it was so good. Perfectly done and way better than I expected!

I ordered mainly for the pizza, but the sides kinda stole the show tbh. The garlic bread was still warm, cheesy, and not all dry, and the dips tasted fresh too. Even the fries were crispy when they got here, which I wasnt expecting. Solid overall, def adding sides again next time.

I’ve ordered from yardsalepizza quite a few times now, i didn’t expect it to be this consistent. Usually with pizza delivery, I kind of assume something might be off eventually, like a soggy crust, cold pizza, or toppings looking different every time. But so far, it’s always shown up hot, the toppings are pretty much the same amount each order, and the crust has been solid every time. Ordering is simple too, which I appreciate. It’s become one of my regular pizza spots because I know what I’m getting, and they haven’t let me down yet.

I’ve ordered from Yard Sale Pizza a few times now and, the ingredients always taste really fresh. The cheese is actually good, not that rubbery stuff you get from some places, and the sauce has a proper nice flavour to it. The only slight downside is I’ve had to wait a bit longer than expected once or twice, which was a bit annoying when I was starving. But the pizza itself has always been worth it. Even simple toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms taste better than most places near me, and the crust is great too. Nothing overly fancy, just really solid pizza made with good stuff

I had a good feeling when I saw how fresh the veggies looked, i was right. The pizza tasted great and disappeared fast once everyone started grabbing slices.